Tim Nash
Global Moderator Community Supporter?
Internet Junkie
Posts: 2173
5036 credits Members referred : 2
Venture Skills - New Media & IT group
« on: May 02, 2007, 11:36:03 AM »
Kevin Rose has published the HD DVD code on the Digg blog declaring
Quote
But now, after seeing hundreds of stories and reading thousands of comments, you’ve made it clear. You’d rather see Digg go down fighting than bow down to a bigger company. We hear you, and effective immediately we won’t delete stories or comments containing the code and will deal with whatever the consequences might be.
If we lose, then what the hell, at least we died trying.
This after a day when the Digg team attempted to censor the code on Digg after receiving a cease and desist notice from their sponsor! The following 24 hours caused mayhem, resulting in Digg temporarily shutting down submission and promotion after being flooded with stories.
Tim Nash
Global Moderator Community Supporter?
Internet Junkie
Posts: 2173
5036 credits Members referred : 2
Venture Skills - New Media & IT group
« Reply #2 on: May 02, 2007, 11:46:22 AM »
The string code, is the private key that unlocks the DRM on HD DVD, on its own it's meaningless but if you also know the algorithm used you can effectively unlock a HD DVD. A Digger submitted a story about TShirt that had the keystring on it, and was banned for breaching Digg TOS which they had updated after they had been sent a cease and desist notice by Diggnation sponsors. Over the following 24 hours the world went mental!
Interesting, as Digg is a popular bookmarking tool...even if I use del.icio.us .
@Nikolas: Not at all. In fact, Maximum PC showed the world how to rip protected CDs and DVDs to their computers...
Tim Nash
Global Moderator Community Supporter?
Internet Junkie
Posts: 2173
5036 credits Members referred : 2
Venture Skills - New Media & IT group
« Reply #5 on: May 02, 2007, 11:55:36 AM »
Nope the keystring is only a set of numbers, it would be illegal to show the algorithm which is patented. If I posted a password here I wouldn't be breaking the law in the UK/Europe or state side however if I then used that password to gain entry I would be breaking the law.
Same thing, The lawyers sent a cease and desist because they believed that the algorithm had been included the keystring is without that worthless.
@Nikolas: Not at all. In fact, Maximum PC showed the world how to rip protected CDs and DVDs to their computers...
Not the same thing really Nathan, we are talking about showing a patented algorithm and if its legal, an article on how to copy CD's or DVD's would never cover how to break the DRM other then point to programs that could do it as examples of it being done very different. If the article showed how to write a program to decrypt DVD encryption then it would be the same.
Ah, okay...just thought I'd point out that ripping encrypted CDs is illegal in the US and Canada...and that Max PC showed people how to do it, step by step .
Tim Nash
Global Moderator Community Supporter?
Internet Junkie
Posts: 2173
5036 credits Members referred : 2
Ah, okay...just thought I'd point out that ripping encrypted CDs is illegal in the US and Canada
no its not! ripping CD's to which you do not own the copyright is illegal and even then its only illegal if you supply it to some one else or use it (i.e listen to it) the actual copying is not illegal.
However the articles will be describing how to rip an encrypted CD that you are legally entitled to now of course you could go and illegally rip a cd using the same method...
« Last Edit: May 03, 2007, 09:15:48 AM by ventureskills »
IGU on this topic...can't post anything here without getting jumped on. One final question: Have you ever read Maximum PC Magazine?
Tim Nash
Global Moderator Community Supporter?
Internet Junkie
Posts: 2173
5036 credits Members referred : 2
Venture Skills - New Media & IT group
« Reply #11 on: May 03, 2007, 09:13:45 AM »
actually yes... More importantly Future Publishing its owners are one of the largest publishers of magazines in the world, they certainly have more lawyers up until yesterday then Digg