Which site is better?

Here is my old one:
http://www.theugly-club.com/uglymenu.html


Here is a different one. This is kind of rough. The part where the blog is is just where the actual page conent would go.
http://www.theugly-menu.com/uglynew.html

Which should I use?

[Join us @ facebook]

The second is not loading here.

Nick
I think he meant to this url http://www.theugly-club.com/uglynew.html

I like the first menu as a presentation but I hate that it opens up a new window for each navigation button
(it is very annoying) and I am pretty sure most people would agree with me

I would never visit a site again with such a behaviour

[Free WordPress Themes]

I don't have links on that new page

anyway the old one is more fun...

[Guest]

[59.828]

Googlebot