Advice on Link Exchanges

[Page Rank is not a guide]

Link exchanges are cool, and this forum is a great place to get in touch with people to exchange links but, I thought I would offer some basic but worthwhile advice to ease the link exchanging process.

Page Rank is not a guide - Sorry but I need to link to sites PR4 or higher is a waste of words, PR has no influence on where you appear in SERP (search engine results page), Linking to lower PR sites does not decrease your ranking, and any tool your using to work out your PR is wrong! Google uses PR as a very loose guide to the level of inbound links to a site, it is not a reflection of quality or a mark of experience.

Page Strength is a guide - Page strength is all the things people think PR is. It is a guide both to popularity and relative importance of a page along with its potential impact on SERPs at the current time. When asking for link exchanges use Page strength no Page rank to determine your page strength visit SEOmoz page strength tool don't be disheartened if the number is lower then your PR (nearly every ones is)

However Page ranking/strength changes, so don't worry to much about either, its the site your interested in, does it have potential visitors, if the site looks and feels wrong then its page rank/strength is irrelevant.

Reciprocal or 3 way linking - When working our a link exchange you should be prepared if a person asks wether your interested in reciprocal or 3 way linking. Reciprocal linking is where 2 sites link to each other directly it is what most link exchanges are about. 3 way linking is when you have 3 web sites (often 2 belong to one person, one the other) they each link to once site so A -> B -> C -> A. The principle behind this is that Google gives much more validity to one way non reciprocal links (this has yet to be proven, though Google algorithm can spot interlinked link farms a mile off so they do have some sort of checking) for more information check out this wikipedia article and SEObook entry on whether 3 way link exchanges are a good idea

Relative Links - Presuming your linking to sites within your own field where will the links be placed, within relevant content? or on a links page, or sidebar. The most prized links are those that sit within relative content, so links within the page of content, much like the links within this forum post, second most prized are links in sidebars on certain pages (particularly home page) least prized are link pages, which do not provide any real relevancy and are often not included in Google except in supplemental results. When asking for link exchanges make sure you know where you are going to put the link and vice versa.

Check the site before agreeing - Check the site your linking to, is it somewhere you want to be associated with, things to avoid are MFA (made for adsense) and other here today gone tomorrows sites, overly adverts, sites using pop ups etc. If your not comfortable then don't agree to link until they make changes, rememmber you will have reasons to say no, tell them as they may have no idea what's wrong.

No to no follow - This is an obvious one make sure niether party uses no follow attribute on link exchanges, you are offering an association with the site so the use of no follow is hardly appropriate in such cases.

Time limits & review - Agree a minimum time the links should be up, and also suggest a review date, after a month or two to see if the exchange is working.

[Join us @ facebook]

Nice advices. Thread is now sticky

I will strongly agree that 3 way linking is the best way to exchange links because search engines will not "realize" that there is an exchange between the sites so the ranking will be better.

Pagerank is not much, but when you get a high pagerank from quality links (from relevant web sites) you are on a very good way

[Free WordPress Themes]

yes thats a great guide ! thanks...

I think a PR higher then 5 is also a good indicator about the quality of a website (right that's not a rule).

I think checking  the page strength is a good an fast way to "judge" about link partner.

BTW do you write this guides especially for webdigity?

yep its a webdigity unique classic

[Free WordPress Themes]

When asking for link exchanges use Page strength no Page rank to determine your page strength visit SEOmoz page strength tool Visit through proxy don't be disheartened if the number is lower then your PR (nearly every ones is)

finalwebsites.com is one of them:



 

Don't worry remember its a totally different index to PR and most sites have a lower score.

[Join us @ facebook]

yep its a webdigity unique classic

That's why I like you so much

BTW webdigity has 4.5 page strength. I wouldn't expect that

[Free WordPress Themes]

hehe great Nick,

I'm sure that a MFA site will never have a good page strength but sometimes good websites have a lower value than others, in my case:

finalwebsites has a 3.5 and has around 600-800 visitors a day from Google (good SEO and content) while my template shop has a value of 4 and only 100 visitors a day

but sure all together are good indecators

I agree with most of the points raised, but I would not altogether throw out PagRank.  Becasue PageRank is logorithmis (am I using the right word?), PR1 and 2 are almost worth nothing, whereas PR4 is worth perhaps dozens of times what PR2 is.  And PageRank of accumulated links does count.

That being said, if a page is highly relevant, I don't hesitate to to accept link swaps even from PR0 pages if the page is a_ indexed or b) likely to send real traffic.

With regard to 2-way vs 3-way, I am not sure it really matters if your link campaign is broad (swaps, articles, social bookmarking, blogging, directories, etc.)  It might play more of a factor if your website is heavily dependend on link swaps, but I can't help but think that Google tracks websites that appear to be gaming them by an overreliance on 3-way link exchanges.

Throw out page rank, any page rank your seeing is up to 6 months out of date, so its only an indicator of things in the past, it has no relevance what so ever to anything other then an internal (Google) system for links and they are the only people who know your current PR and what the value is actually for. I'm not saying don't include it in your proposal but only because there are still people out there under the belief that page rank is some how useful to work out whether you should link to a site.

It really does need to be re-emphasised that it has nothing to do with how relevant or the quality of a link. You would be better of getting a PR0 link in your subject then a PR10 in a completely separately subject. PR has a place in some areas but link building is one area where you just need to ignore it,

The biggest flaw that many forget when chasing links with pre-existing PR is that 3, 6, 9 or even 12 months down the road today's PR0 could become tomorrow's PR6.

I don't consider PR when deciding to exchange links. With my directory, many of the sites being submitted are on the newer side. The trick is to use your gut feel when deciding the potential value of a link to or from a site. I'd much rather have a link from/to a weakly designed but useful site than one that has perfect markup and just feels scummy somehow.

Nice post. Thanks for sharing this information

[Philippine Beach Resorts Blog]

checked one of my free-hosted hobby sites and this is what came up...

 

personally, i dont exchange links. i prefer one-way incoming links.

[Free WordPress Themes]

personally, i dont exchange links. i prefer one-way incoming links.

I think everyone does...

great this high page strength result!

[Philippine Beach Resorts Blog]

i cant make that thing work. i dont have much experience with those tags...

[Free WordPress Themes]

i cant make that thing work. i dont have much experience with those tags...

I fixed it for you )

[Free WordPress Themes]

checked one of my free-hosted hobby sites and this is what came up...

 

personally, i dont exchange links. i prefer one-way incoming links.

actually a lot of the values in this test are based on the domain name and not on the URL, sorry man but this rank is fake

[Philippine Beach Resorts Blog]

i know that man... still the full url has 337 incoming links and i dont know where they came from. i remember submitting to only less than 10 directories and others (i cant remember anymore)before and thats it.

[Philippine Beach Resorts Blog]

and thanks for fixing that logo for me!

[Free WordPress Themes]

i know that man... still the full url has 337 incoming links and i dont know where they came from. i remember submitting to only less than 10 directories and others (i cant remember anymore)before and thats it.

I think it's a google thing

[Guest]

[35.590]

Googlebot, Yahoo crawler, Gigabot, Nikolas, Baidu Spider